As much as I have been enjoying this current iteration of DuckTales, there was always something that was nagging at me, something about the show that felt off. There have been a number of epic, amazing episodes, with some fascinating, ballsy revelations, but the one thing that stuck in my craw the most? The absolute non-ending to “The Spear Of Selene!” which struck me more as a weird, panicky “we don’t know how to end this” kind of thing. It (alongside my genuine bafflement on the show’s “anti-mine cart chases” crusade) represents a certain… I don’t know–discomfort? reluctance?–that DuckTales often struggled with. It would try too hard, or maybe not hard enough–a lot of time with its villains (Beaks, Glomgold), but also with its themes and meta commentary about adventuring, self-awareness, and nostalgia trips. DuckTales gradually got more and more comfortable with the world it created and the ideas it generated, but it still felt like it was trying to establish itself and really figure out what it wants to be. Yet if this premiere is any indication, DuckTales has finally learned to just relax and be a fun, adventure show.
It’s pretty much the theme of “Challenge Of The Senior Junior Woodchucks” (B+). Heck, at the end, Scrooge provides a short speech about ignoring the treasure at the end of an adventure and just enjoy the journey where ever that adventure takes you. Maybe I’m reading too much into things, but it feels like a subtle rebuke of all the previous episodes’ attempts to find meaning, criticism, analysis, or commentary on adventuring. Watching this group of ducks venture forth, following a map before detouring on an outlandish but more productive journey following a wacky, singing bird, was just fun. At this point, DuckTales have gotten quite acquainted with all its characters to the point that they can weave in and out of a large group outing like this and make them all mesh together hilariously and wondrously. This isn’t the first produced episode of the season, but it’s clear why Disney debuted it first. Everyone at this point just clicks. Except for Huey.
I’ve mentioned before that Huey seemed like the one character the show couldn’t quite get a handle on. He had a knack for meticulous organization but he never seemed to quite click into focus (he really “led” one episode last season, an clunky episode that furthers my point). Giving him a clear goal here, and showcasing how his organizational skills and dedication to the Junior Woodchucks is both his strength and his weakness, allows the triplet to finally shine as a specific character. His need to be a Senior Woodchuck makes sense, due to his deification of the Guidebooks–and to be fair, a lot of the lessons get him through quite a bit of the journey. But his obsession with winning it becomes all-consuming, both causing an illusory floating book to appear along side him (voiced by the always game Stephen Root), and him cruelly leaving behind his opponent, Violet Sabrewing, in a vicarious position. Huey dedicates and defines himself through the Woodchucks, but he gets so caught up in the prestige of being an instant top dog that he forgets the basic rule of compassion and altruism. Violet shows this by saving his life before perishing in a fire, as well as her openness to her past failures for the promotion. That Huey let Violet win shows both his learned gratefulness and humility, knowing he can try again in the future (Della sticking up for him is a nice touch and great showcase for her character). This episode gives Huey purpose, drive, and a strong lesson that brings his character clarity, even if perhaps a little more insight would have been great to see. We have a whole season for that though.
It’s no coincidence that the “Quack Pack” (A) follows a Huey-centric episode. Huey is the only character who realizes that something is wrong when the cast of DuckTales suddenly finds themselves in the very specific setup of a sitcom–including a laugh track, clearly defined sets, and stock catchphases. His sharp, specific sense of organization and routine has him suspicious during the cold opening, but it’s when he discovers his Junior Woodchuck Guidebook is blank that he snaps out of the spell and begins to question his surroundings. Using an empty guidebook is the perfect catalyst to Huey’s realization that his family is trapped in the safe, formulaic rhythms of a sitcom–and the tropes/beats of a sitcom are satirized perfectly. From the reactions, the close-ups, the broad gestures, that intro: “Quack Pack” really nails the typical sitcom patter, and while “parodying sitcoms” has been done to death by this time, Bob Snow’s script keeps things moving while maintaining the specific character details that almost suggest that DuckTales could, perhaps, work as one. (Della and Webby are by far the standouts.)
But what gives “Quack Pack” its power is not only how the episode ties its nostalgic bent into its story, but how it’s utilized within the desires of the show’s most important low-key character: Donald. Donald has been the surprising breakout of DuckTales, not only because his physical antics are hilarious, but his emotional drive has been the most visceral and palpable. In the midst of yet another dangerous adventure, Donald, inadvertently rubbing a magic lamp, wishes he and his family would just have normal family problems. This snaps everyone into the sitcom world, and Donald–with his smooth, wish-fulfillment, Don Cheadle voice–happily accepts the “normal” family world they now inhabit. Donald is tired, frustrated, and genuinely, perpetually worried about his family and all the danger they’re put into. He just wishes they could be normal. Many shows have utilized the “comfortable sitcom world” to mask/reveal the fears of a central character–Bojack Horseman, Mr. Robot, and even Steven Universe. DuckTales embraces it in its own specific way, through Donald’s genuine fears, and through the use of Gene, the genie from “Treasure Of The Lost Lamp!” Jaleel White voices him, and he is so game and entertaining, a force of neutral chaos that genies tend to be. But it’s Goofy that manages to talk Donald into returning to the real world. He emphasizes that all families are “not normal” in their own ways, and the crazy adventures are the ones that generates the best, strongest memories. (In a complete coincidence, a recent great episode of Bob’s Burgers has that exact same theme.)
Donald makes the wish and returns everyone back to the “real” world, finally accepting the state and the circumstances his family thrive in–at least for now. A bit more insight into Donald would be cool (I’m always begging for this, I know), but “Quack Pack” is running on all cylinders, with both the details and the depths of the episode being exemplary–too many for me to recount on a review that’s already running too long. Both episodes seem to acknowledge, at some level, that DuckTales is finally just comfortable with itself, easing into its stories about family, adventures, and the wild combinations of the two, without the pressure of its legacy and the need to (meta)comment so much upon it. This is going to be one heck of a hurricane.
Stray observations
- We only seen them together-together sparingly, but the just the few times Donald and Della pop up here are gold. Della helps her brother get untangled from film and tries to keep him calm in the face of an antagonistic natural world. But a shock from some lighting rain infuriates her, and she whips out some uncanny perfect Donald-esque tantrums. It’s incredible, and I want to see them on a fully-fledged adventure together.
- The final leg of the Senior Woodchuck competition has Huey and Violet crossing a rickety bridge over actual lava. That such an immediate, literal danger is a generic part of a course for children works better than the idea of the only duck family just being attracted to/compelled by dangerous adventures. Everyone in this crazy world has to deal with chaos instead of just Scrooge and his immediate family/compatriots.
- UPDATE: I just had to quickly but importantly mention Violet looks to have two gay fathers. Such a great and valid step in the right direction on LGBT depiction in cartoons!
- I’m glad “Quack Pack” doesn’t make any jokes at the expense of the original actual Quack Pack (except in broad, meta terms). I’m willing to go to bat for that show. It definitely engaged in a lot of “COOL, EXTREME, RADICAL 90s TEENS” visuals, but that was for the marketing. Huey, Dewey, and Louie may have appeared to be surfing, quad-riding, paragliding “bros” in the promos, but in the show, they were goofy, inexperienced, clumsy, awkward, and kind of dumb. You know–teenagers. Donald was fantastic, and Daisy was great as well. Not every episode was a winner, but I highly recommend the episode “Can’t Take a Yolk.” It’s Quack Pack’s way of doing meta-comedy, and it’s hilarious. If you have Disney+, I strongly recommend it.
- I don’t know how they can bring Goofy back into the show proper since he’s a product of the sitcom world, but it would be great to really see him, and Max, fit into this world. (I know he’s technically real at the end as a GUEST STAR, but it’s hard to tell if that’s just part of the grand joke about his appearance. Bill Farmer is a treasure, though).
- This season looks like it’ll have the family tracking various lost treasures from the journal of Isabella Finch, (late?) Chief of Woodchuck Exploration, with the mysterious F.O.W.L. hot on their heels. Intriguing!
- We’re just reviewing the premiere of this show folks! Maybe we’ll do a drop in or check out the finale, but that’s all up in the air for now!
37 Comments
Those were both pretty solid episodes; shame there won’t be weekly reviews, but this AV Club is a fickle business, I guess.The way they employ Donald still bugs me. Is Tony Anselmo just getting too old, and they want to limit what’s needed of him? If it’s “Donald talks funny,” that’s never stopped literally any other Disney production before (House of Mouse made jokes here and there about how unintelligible he is, and he was limited on the OG Ducktales, but that’s really it.).
My favorite part is that the season looks set to focus largely on Huey, after Dewey was the big star of Season 1 and Louie of Season 2. That has to have been deliberate, and I look forward to it coming to fruition.
I sure hope so. He’s still pretty defined by his nerdiness and could really use more dimensions.
I like that they’re defined at all. I couldn’t tell them apart in the original series.
I’m pretty sure in the original series you weren’t supposed to be able to tell them apart.
“I’m so angry I can’t even alliterate.” I love you, Uncle Scrooge.
As a gay man, I’m happy to see LGBT representation in cartoons. I thought that Violet had two dads when Lena said something like “That’s my sister from two misters” in the beginning of the episode, but we got confirmation when we saw the two dads (each wearing an “I’m with Dad” shirt) at the end.
It was pretty quick but they were next to Lena wearing those shirts when she said that too
Lightning rain sounds absolutely terrifying.
I got the impression that Goofy was real. The wish was fighting to preserve itself at the same time that Goofy was convincing Donald to be happy with his family the way they are, directly leading to Donald’s undoing the wish.
I love everything about Gene. He’s from 1990, when his movie came out. (I loved that movie waaaay more than did anyone else I knew.) He’s so ’90s that he’s turning DuckTales into Quack Pack and playing pogs in his downtime.
DuckTales’s idea of humans is super creepy. I’m almost offended. You do know I’m a human watching a show about these duck people, right, DuckTales?
It’s weirder to me that they can’t fly. In the woodchuck episode when Violet made her hang glider, it hit me- wait, they’re birds…
So, a little more meta-commentary, the original Quack Pack had human secondary characters, and they were all designed like these.
Not all of Quack Pack’s humans came across as creepy monsters, though.
The logical conclusion is that the lamp in “Quack Pack” is from the book from “Challenge.”As an aside, I like how they lampshade having already done an episode inspired by the DuckTales movie with a line about “How many lamps did that guy have?!”
Apparently, breaking the fourth wall is very, very bad.
“We’re just reviewing the premiere of this show folks! Maybe we’ll do a
drop in or check out the finale, but that’s all up in the air for now!”Augh! This always happens! I love AV Club reviews but the show reviews I like always get dropped in favor of promoting more Kinja deals on Amazon. >:(
Actually, at the end of “Quack Pack” Della asked why Goofy was still there, to which Gene explained he was a guest star, hinting that he is real. Also, I think some of the creative team on Twitter have said Goofy is real as well
“Maybe I’m reading too much into things…”Dude, you just wrote how many words on Duck Tales? I think that’s a given.
I’ve only had a chance to check out the first episode, not Quack Pack, but I found it kinda meh. The A-Plot with Huey is a plot device I’ve seen dozens of times before, even back when I was a kid myself, and even back then it irritated the hell outta me. And this episode does absolutely nothing to stand out from the other 5,000 times cartoons have used this plot. Even the ultimate lesson is the exact same as every other time this plot is used. Doesn’t help that I’m pretty “meh” on Violet either.The B-Plot with the Duck family was far more entertaining and enjoyable, but it had the same complaint I always have about this show: Lack of Donald. Sure, he tags along with the family the whole episode, but he only has, like, 5 lines the whole episode and 3 of them were generic angry quacking while one was a single word said with the rest of the family. I know I’ve said this dozens of times on this show, but I despise how much they’ve marginalized Donald’s role. I honestly kind of wish they had just sent him off with the Navy like the original show.
OK, watched Quack Pack. Can’t give it the glowing praise others are giving it. Granted, I don’t watch modern sitcoms, but most of the older ones I watched don’t overuse the laughtrack nearly that bad. It was grating almost immediately. Also, I don’t think any show in the last 40 years has used those kinds of transitions between scenes. And I may be wrong, but Goofy himself felt off. I think maybe it was that he just wasn’t tall enough? I feel like other Disney stuff has him twice Donald’s height, and here he felt shorter.I admit that I may have been put off from the start due to Donald. I know I keep bitching about him getting more focus, but then they brought back Don Cheadle. I understand why, since this Donald despises his voice, but it just immediately soured me on the episode as a whole. Maybe if this was the first time this was done and we got a ton of Donald in the previous two seasons I wouldn’t mind, but it just kind of epitomized all the problems I have with this show’s treatment of the Duck. In a positive, I absolutely adored Scrooge’s & Donald’s classic outfits on them as well as the triplet’s Quack Pack-inspired outfits and I wish they were the defaults from now on.
That 70’s Show was a sitcom that used exactly those silly scene transitions. But I’ll give DuckTales the benefit of the doubt, and hope they didn’t only see that and go “Hey, that’s from the 90s, let’s use it!” (The anachronistic irony, is that was a 90s show riffing on a 70s trope- a trend en vogue at the time, thanks to the popularity of Austin Powers.) So I’m sure they were drawing from other kids sitcoms that also used those transitions. I may be mis-remembering, but I think Boy Meets World did in their very first season. Clarissa Explains It All and Home Improvement utilized them as well.
I can understand “Quack Pack” coming off as a bit grating. They skated right on the edge for me, but they hung in there. Along with the overuse of laugh track, I take it the main idea was to go for the hodgepodge of general sitcom tropes, as EXCESSIVLEY as possible for maximum satire. Mistaken identities, non sequiturs, Launchpad’s 3 dates- they won me over, lol. But a small touch they missed that I really wanted to see was a second set of stairs in the kitchen!
Third Rock from the Sun also had them as well.
This isn’t the first produced episode of the season, but it’s clear why Disney debuted it first.To be fair, the first two season 3 episodes they produced were the Halloween special and the Christmas special, respectively, so Disney has those ready to whip out at the appropriate times of the year. I’m reasonably sure this was intended to be the premiere, but don’t quote me on that (there could have been more produced before this one, I dunno).
Not following the season – are you ducking kidding me? This Drake’s crying fowl!
What’s the source for saying this isn’t the first episode produced? If there episodes are out of order again, it would be good to know where to look for the real order.
Change Your Life Right Now! Work From Comfort Of Your Home And Receive Your First Paycheck Within A Week. No Experience Needed, No Boss Over Your Shoulder… Say Goodbye To Your Old Job! Limited Number Of Spots Open…Find out how HERE……https://bit.ly/2x2gvGo
I thought it was a nice touch to have the crazy audience be humans. Also the nods to the Genie (and Max) made this 90s kid very happy. I used to watch Treasure of the Lost Lamp a lot. Rip Taylor was perfect in that role.
I wish there would be weekly reviews. Would like Kevin’s thoughts on last season’s introduction of Bombie the Zombie, who was obviously retooled, from more *ahem* problematic origins.
https://tv.avclub.com/it-takes-a-literal-monster-for-louie-to-learn-humility-1837822906
Really hope Gene the genie comes back in another episode. Typical DuckTales to pack in so many great ideas that you feel some get shortchanged for screen time, but there’s so much potential for Gene to become this show’s Great Gazoo/Mr. Mxyzptlk. Being voiced by 90’s icon Jaleel White doesn’t hurt either.I’m glad someone made the call to stick Goofy in at the end to confirm he exists properly in-universe. For all this show likes to tease fan service, it also does so in subversive, almost-controversial ways. But at least the final shot of Goofy opens up the door for more appearances, and also Max. I found the Woodchuck episode fairly standard for the most part, though I got a laugh from the JWG burning up “I don’t know! Why are you imagining this?!” Plus loving Della in full Woodchuck gear throwing a tantrum. Also, great to see her added to the opening.
Where are people seeing these? Season 3 isn’t showing up on the Disney+ app for me
On actual Disney (XD). Season 3 probably won’t be on + until the season is finished.
It’s a bummer these won’t continue weekly, especially since there’s a shortage of new media presently. If you like this reboot, you’ll dIt’s on Netflix.
Man I’d rather talk about episode 3 then this two.
You guys should at least review the James Bond episode, it’s so so good