In Till, Chinonye Chukwu brings to vivid life a tragic chapter in American history
Featuring Danielle Deadwyler in a mesmerizing performance, Chinonye Chukwu's follow-up to Clemency examines Emmett Till's death—and life—with power and urgency
Film Reviews Chinonye Chukwu
Emmett Till was kidnapped, tortured, and lynched in Mississippi in 1955 because he whistled at a white woman. This is history—a story that every Black American knows all too well. In the new film Till, that black mark in American history is told best in a grave and concise moment that shows his mother, Mamie Till Mobley, standing over his mutilated body and declaring “My son’s body returned to me reeking of racial hatred.” It’s a moment registered in books and magazine covers, and it’s exactly what audiences need to see and hear in a movie that tells this story.
Director Chinonye Chukwu made a name for herself with the incisive and precise Clemency (2019). Here she takes on the enormous task of dramatizing the events of the murder of Emmett Till and its aftermath, perhaps an impossible one, but she handles it with aplomb. The film starts with Chicago native Till (Jalyn Hall) as he prepares to leave for Mississippi to visit his cousins. His mother Mamie Till Mobley (Danielle Deadwyler) worries about the visit because she understands how Black people are treated in the South. “Be small there,” is her advice to him. We know what happens next. The film does not show the lynching—not a spoiler since it’s outlined in the marketing and a director’s statement—but rather what happened before and after.
Chukwu has shown a great knack for collaboration with actors and drawing marvelous performances out of them (see Alfre Woodard and Aldis Hodge’s staggering work in Clemency). She evidences it again with Deadwyler in Till. Centering the film on Mamie is the right decision, and Deadwyler absolutely delivers—she’s heartbreaking from literally her first moment on screen, able to demonstrate not just a mother’s love but also her resilience. Wherever Chukwu places her camera, Deadwyler’s face makes us understand not just what Mamie is going through but rather the reality of what this country does to its Black citizens. It’s a performance of quiet strength and loud emotion, though Deadwyler is never loud or histrionic. She just simmers with profound pain.
Whoopi Goldberg as Alma Carthan, Mamie’s mother and Emmet’s grandmother, is a casting coup. As expected, she brings gravitas and warmth to the brief role. However, what makes this particularly meaningful is that we all know and love Whoopi, who most audiences have known for most of their lives—whether because of Celie in The Color Purple (1985) or being on TV every day in our homes. She’s familiar to us. She’s family. And because of that, seeing her as Emmet Till’s family makes this story more urgent, more personal. It happened in our family. Therein lies the strength of this film.
Chukwu has personalized Till, or “Bobo” as he’s lovingly referred to by family, so that he’s not just a symbol. He’s flesh and blood, he’s a boy who enjoys teasing his mother, hanging out with his cousins. More importantly, he’s full of joy. That joy defines the last few days of his life, and Hall leans into showing it so that the audience feels the acute pain of his absence. And whenever he’s with Deadwyler, everything becomes more real because of her grounded and ferocious performance.
The film is also strong in portraying the familial bonds of the extended Till family and the guilt they carried for not being able to prevent the murder. As Moses Wright, on whose watch Emmett Till was kidnapped, John Douglas Thompson sensitively modulates an admittance of guilt and culpability.
The script, credited to Michael Reilly, Keith Beauchamp, and Chukwu, is less successful. In attempting to provide historical context and give credit to the many brave people who mobilized for the trial of Till’s murderers, it loses some focus. There’s an economy in the narrative in Mamie’s scenes, with just the right information given to the audience. Chukwu trusts Deadwyler to deliver the pathos needed in scenes bursting with strong emotion. But the trial and what’s around it, in contrast, are full of exposition. Many characters are introduced by name and given a moment to tell us what their historical link to the story is, but beyond providing an a-ha moment for the audience and cementing everybody’s historical role, these bits stop the narrative dead in its tracks.
Additionally, the score by Abel Korzeniowski is a tad too melodramatic—especially after Deadwyler has avoided all of that. She doesn’t need the bombast and all the audience needs is her perceptive and stoic performance. And otherwise, the film’s visuals are not distinctive. But the moments that are most powerful in Till are those where Chukwu concentrates on people’s faces filling the screen, both actors and extras. After all, history is told by the people who witness it.
19 Comments
He was lynched for ALLEGEDLY whistling at a white woman. IIRC the woman in question eventually admitted he never actually whistled at her.
She recanted the accusations that Till grabbed her and made suggestive comments to her while inside her store, but the whistle was outside and witnessed by several other people, including members of Till’s family.Now, there’s been some dispute as to whether he was intentionally whistling at Bryant, with his mother insisting that he was whistling to overcome his stutter, and others saying he was whistling at a move in a checkers game nearby. But the late Simeon Wright, Till’s cousin who was there at the time, was always adamant that it was a wolf whistle that Till directed at Bryant as a joke to make his companions laugh, not realizing how taboo it would be in Mississippi.
Ah okay, that clarifies it a bit.
He was cat calling, plain and simple. He didn’t deserve to die, but he is hardly blameless here. Cat calling can make white women feel very unsafe. Ask any white woman, oh, and believe whatever they say.
I didn’t think she recanted. Rather, she wrote up an account that leaked recently in which she reiterated her claims.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Am_More_Than_a_Wolf_Whistle
She was interviewed by Timothy Tyson, for his book The Blood of Emmett Till, in 2017 and he claimed that she had recanted certain parts of her story during the interview, but that he was unable to record her saying that on tape. It’s possible that her feelings had changed in the decade or so between her memoir and that interview, but it’s also important to note she’s not officially on record has having recanted anything.
the woman with Bryant at the interviews, her daughter-in-law, Marsha Bryant, says that Bryant never told Tyson thathttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emmett_Till#Encounter_between_Till_and_Carolyn_Bryant
Till had a lisp and accidentally whistled when he talked. That was described by John Edgar Wideman in Writing to Save a Life, which I recommend. The book also discusses how Till’s father was ALSO lynched for supposed crimes against a white woman.
Lynching is informal. His father was formally executed by the Army for rape & murder.
I wasn’t impressed by the trailer and thought during that it is a shame that this will be a vehicle for this story, but maybe it was that one trailer that didn’t win me over. Hopefully the film does his story justice.
Even the trailer for this is so upsetting. I can’t stomach an evening of child murder. And, of course, as with so many other things, the people who need to see something like this never will.
What bugs me more are the people who will take in two hours of black trauma as entertainment and conflate the experience with being personally and societally past racism.
concurred!
i always wonder for whom these movies are made.
I’m so confused – bugs you more than what?
Clemency is a powerful film and watching Woodard hammer herself into the shape of the lead character will have a lasting effect on the viewer.
I want to see this, and I want to bring my tween kid to see this. But honestly I am afraid. I watched Eyes on the Prize as a child, and seeing Till’s face was deeply traumatic (as well it should be) – so much so that I still go out of my way to avoid seeing the image. I have to assume it’s recreated here, and I’m not sure I’m ready to see it, or to visit that same trauma on my kid.
And because of that, seeing her as Emmet Till’s family makes this story more urgent, more personal.
You should probably make sure to spell his name correctly.
It’s not tragic, it’s evil because the bitch that got him killed is still alive AND free.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/emmett-till-carolyn-bryant-donham-grand-jury-declines-to-indict/Carolyn BryantGrand jury declines to indict Carolyn Bryant … – CBS News
Lol this is the definition of a criticism proof movie. No matter what they think of it, no one is going to give this a bad review.