Exploring Tim Burton’s world of outsiders and misfits

Why does the director embrace wonderful weirdos like Edward Scissorhands and Jack Skellington? Look to his past for answers

Film Features Tim Burton
Exploring Tim Burton’s world of outsiders and misfits
Clockwise from left: Tim Burton (Wikipedia), Batman Returns (Warner Bros.), The Nightmare Before Christmas (Buena Vista Pictures), Edward Scissorhands (20th Century Fox), Frankenweenie (Walt Disney Studios) Image: The A.V. Club

Director-animator-artist Tim Burton is known for creating memorable on-screen characters that appeal to outsiders, loners, misfits, goths, and anyone who feels out of step with the mainstream. Characters such as Edward Scissorhands, The Nightmare Before Christmas’ Jack Skellington, Frankenweenie’s Victor Frankenstein, and Beetlejuice’s Lydia Deetz probably wouldn’t exist had Burton had a happy, vanilla, traditional childhood. And as Burton officially reaches senior citizen age—he turned 65 on August 25—the isolation, the oddness, and the troubles he experienced in his youth still echo in his films. From Batman’s struggle with duality to Edward Scissorhands’ feelings of suburban loneliness to Jack Skellington’s childlike enthusiasm for everything Halloween, Burton’s essence is reflected in his characters. The result? An inspired career chock-full of iconic, aggressively unique fictional beings that resonate more than any other filmmaker.

Burton’s embrace of weird and wonderful outcasts dates to his earliest days. Burton was born on August 25, 1958 in sunny Burbank, California, the family home sitting under the flight path of Burbank Airport. His father was a former minor league baseball player who worked for the Burbank Parks and Recreation Department, and his mother later owned a cat-themed gift shop. Burton has said that his parents were emotionally distant and that he felt isolated growing up in the suburbs. He was bullied at school, didn’t have many friends, and spent a lot of his spare time exploring graveyards, reading Edgar Allan Poe, playing with his dog, and, yes, watching movies.

Burton prepares for reel life

Vincent & Frankenweenie

At age 12, Burton’s relationship with his mother became so strained that he moved in with his grandmother. He retreated into his imagination and started making 8mm shorts in his backyard. One of his first films, The Island Of Doctor Ago, was made in 1971 when Burton was 13. “I grew up watching the Universal horror movies, Japanese monster movies, and pretty much any kind of monster movie,” Burton told The Hollywood Reporter. “That was my genre.” Burton also said that his love of Ray Harryhausen’s work got him interested in stop-motion animation at a young age.

At 16, Burton already had his own apartment and began working toward putting himself through the CalArts, the visual and performing arts university located in California. His CalArts short Stalk Of The Celery Monster got the attention of Walt Disney Productions’ animation division, which offered him an apprenticeship. In 1982, Burton made his first short for Disney, titled Vincent. The six-minute stop-motion film is based on a poem by Burton about a little boy who fantasizes about being his hero, Vincent Price (who provided narration for the short). In Burton’s 2000 book, Burton On Burton, he says, “Vincent Price was somebody I could identify with. When you’re younger things look bigger, you find your own mythology, you find what psychologically connects to you.”

Burton’s next short was the stop-motion 1984 film Frankenweenie about a sad boy who brings his beloved dog back to life by using science and electricity, just like Dr. Frankenstein. In both shorts, the outsider protagonists are based upon Burton’s own experiences and essentially represent him as a youth. “You have a dog that you love, and the idea of keeping it alive was the impulse for the film,” says Burton in Burton On Burton. Even though Disney and Burton parted ways because the studio of Mickey Mouse and Donald Duck didn’t know what to do with Burton’s darkly gothic and unique work, they eventually got back together and Burton directed a feature-length Frankenweenie for the House of Mouse in 2012.

Heroes who are “strange and usual”

Beetlejuice – I myself am strange and unusual

1988’s Beetlejuice was only Burton’s second feature-length film, but it showcased his signature style and the first Burton project to feature a character clearly inspired by Burton’s childhood. Winona Ryder played Lydia Deetz, a mopey, goth teenager who seemed more interested in communicating with the ghosts living in her house than her living family who doesn’t get her. “I was obsessed with death, like a lot of children,” says Burton in Burton On Burton. “There was a graveyard right next to where I lived … and I used to play there. It was a place where I felt peaceful, comfortable; a whole world of quiet and peace, and also excitement and drama.”

Burton found even greater mainstream blockbuster success with 1989’s Batman starring Michael Keaton. Although Burton obviously did not create the DC character—in fact, he was never a comic book fan—you can understand why the solitary Dark Knight would appeal to Burton more than other superheroes. In Burton On Burton, the director admits that Batman is “a character I could relate to. Having those two sides, a light side and a dark one, and not being able to resolve them … I also see certain aspects of myself in the character.”

It’s telling that so many of Burton’s films were inspired by drawings and writings that he created either as a coping mechanism, a reaction to his perceived outsider status, or as a manifestation of his dark sensibilities. 1993’s The Nightmare Before Christmas—which Burton co-produced and was directed by Henry Selick—is based on a poem Burton wrote in 1982. In the film, Jack Skellington (voiced by Depp) is the king of Halloween Town who unintentionally derails Christmas when he tries to apply his tried-and-true Halloween sensibilities to the people of Christmas Town. In what can be read as Burton’s own justification for his career-long adherence to a darkly theatrical style, Jack learns that it’s best to stick with what you know, even if it’s spooky and macabre. Although Disney thought the movie was “too dark and scary” for children, time proved them wrong, and Burton’s magical musical has become an enduring holiday classic.

A deep connection with Edward Scissorhands

Edward Scissorhands (1990) Trailer #1 | Movieclips Classic Trailers

Of all the oddballs in all of Burton’s movies, is there any that better reflects who Burton is than the titular character in Edward Scissorhands? The character was born from a sketch Burton made as a teenager of a thin man with elongated scissor-like fingers. As the director explains in Burton On Burton, the image “came subconsciously and was linked to a character who wants to touch but can’t … and probably came to the surface when I was a teenager, because it is a very teenage thing. It had to do with relationships. I just felt I couldn’t communicate.”

In the film, Edward is created by a scientist played by Vincent Price, whom we know is one of Burton’s personal heroes. Edward’s tumbleweed of black locks mirrors Burton’s own mop of mad-scientist hair. Edward tries to relate to the residents of the suburban community with manicured lawns in rows that resemble almost any street in Burton’s hometown of Burbank, but at the end of the day he realizes he’ll just never fit in. Edward, like Burton himself, knows that he’s different but accepts that it’s OK to not be like everyone else.

Many of Burton’s other movies (such as Corpse Bride) feature outsider and misfit characters inspired by a childhood during which he found comfort—and inspiration—in retreating into his imagination. Although Burton is now 65, he still seems very much in touch with the bullied child from Burbank who just wanted to make movies. With any Tim Burton film, it’s not hard to see a reflection of that creative, introverted child of suburbia in his characters’ faces. Burton is currently working on Beetlejuice 2, which will feature the return of Winona Ryder as an adult Lydia Deetz. Here’s hoping that all of these years later she still embraces being “strange and unusual,” just like Burton.

25 Comments

  • lattethunder-av says:

    Duh.

  • milligna000-av says:

    Maybe the writers of most of those films should get a tiny bit of credit and mention if we’re talking about “his” world.Caroline Thompson, who wrote the Beetlejuice screenplay – because Tim doesn’t really write female characters, does he? She also wrote Corpse Bride with Thompson and Pettler… and the screenplay for Nightmare Before Christmas which Henry Selick directed with a flair Burton would never get close to. How many times do either of those two EVER get a credit for Nightmare? Nope, gotta put Tim’s name before the title due to a few obvious doodles.
    Scott Alexander and the mighty Larry Karaszewski – because Burton would never in a million fucking years be able to hit the notes they hit in the Ed Wood script by himself. He certainly hasn’t managed anything remotely as good since with any collaborators.
    John August on the Frankenweenie feature and Big Fish. Reubens, Phil Hartman, and Michael Varhol on Big Adventure. I’m not saying he didn’t add visual flair to these worlds with his increasingly tired and supremely limited shtick over the decades. But in the middle of this WGA strike, let’s tip a hat to the folks who REALLY created 99% of these worlds before Tim Burton directed a single frame or creeped on any of the female actors. The folks on the front lines of the strike, a strike totally missing the presence of this great creative world-building genius.
    The goddamn writers.

    • ginnyweasley-av says:

      The worship of the “auteur director” has always been entirely fraudulent and a way to steal credit from the working class people like writers. The same way we uphold the CEO as some kind of genius technical auteur instead of just the, essentially, product marketer and exec recruiter they typically are. The way Burton plasters his name on other’s works is particularly loathsome. Caroline wrote a book about the Nightmare before Christmas and was forced to use the title, “Tim Burton’s Nightmare Before Christmas” Literally putting his name on something she wrote. Disney.com lists the movie with the same title. Again, putting his name on the works of others. A move he didn’t even direct or write!Caroline Thompson deserves more visibility too. Not only writing those films but writing credits on the first Addams Family movie, Homeward Bound, and The Secret Garden. All beloved classics. 

    • ghboyette-av says:

      Well said!

    • Rev2-av says:

      I’ll never understand the virtue signaling of people with anonymous usernames… Every writer you mentioned gets their credit seen every time a person watches those movies. 

    • tvcr-av says:

      Did he actually creep on the female actors?

    • breadnmaters-av says:

      The AVClub recently posted a list of Burton’s best work and The Nightmare was left out. I was disappointed. I do think that Burton has flair but I hope we can agree to disagree on that.

  • thefilthywhore-av says:

    How come people never talk about the well-adjusted, relatively normal people of Tim Burton’s films? They’re the true misfits here!

  • gterry-av says:

    Large Marge sent me.

    • daveassist-av says:

      It was ten years ago on a night just like tonight. Why, tonight’s the anniversary. Worst accident I ever seen.

      But that means the Large Marge I was riding with was…

      • gterry-av says:

        HER GHOST!My favorite part of the Large Marge scene was that Large Marge was apparently only 36 when she died. Also I just realized that the Pee Wee’s Big Adventure Bluray has a commentary tract with Reubens and Burton and I think I really need to listen to that.

  • kreskyologist-av says:

    Jack Skellington is not voiced by Johnny Depp, for pity’s sake. It’s Chris Sarandon and Danny Elfman.

  • daveassist-av says:

    Off-topic, but we lost Bob Barker of the Price is Right.  He was 99.

  • discojoe-av says:

    You should check out Burton’s book, The Melancholy Death of Oyster Boy and other Tales, especially if you like Burton’s odd movie characters.

  • happyinparaguay-av says:

    Jack Skellington (voiced by Depp)

    Uh… was this article written by a deaf person or something? Trying to apply the benefit of the doubt here.

    • TjM78-av says:

      maybe confusing corpse bride

    • steinjodie-av says:

      He was voiced by Chris Sarandon, with the singing done by Danny Elfman.

      • thepetemurray-darlingbasinauthorithy-av says:

        Oh, yeah, of course this guy is a Tim Burton collaborator.

      • medacris-av says:

        I hope the article gets edited to reflect this. Depp isn’t in a number of Tim Burton-related films (including TNBC, which Burton didn’t direct, as well as Big Fish and a number of others).

    • breadnmaters-av says:

      Wow. Elfman’s voice is signature. Chris Sarandon’s voice I’d never heard before. I can’t even remember what Depp’s singing voice sounds like and don’t care. I imagine a lot of intentional belching.

  • simplepoopshoe-av says:

    Have people been here long enough to remember stuff like “popcorn champs” and the rom com column and stuff…? It wasn’t old-old AV club (Dikachu era), but I think it was before the jump from Chicago. Due to the whole “double strikes = no news” thing the AV club should pivot back into content of that nature. Although this piece plus the Sean Connery Bond article don’t inspire confidence that the current staff are good enough writers for that. Please prove me wrong, AV Club.

  • chandlerbinge-av says:

    Is it just me or does the article repeat the same point about Burton’s childhood over and over? Not sure if it’s AI-”assisted” but it reads like a 7th grader stretching his essay to reach the assigned word count.

    • taco-emoji-av says:

      LMAO I thought the same thing and had to google if this author is a real guy. He’s got a LinkedIn profile and other gigs, but AI-assisted sounds right. The factual error and lack of any real voice certainly points that direction.

  • breadnmaters-av says:

    The Nightmare Before Christmas didn’t even get a mention in Burton’s best works (posted recently). I know that Selick directed, but it was a Burton project. It’s also my favorite.

  • taco-emoji-av says:

    Jack Skellington (voiced by Depp) lmao

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share Tweet Submit Pin