Back to the drawing board: 14 TV shows that should do animated episodes

The Boys, Riverdale, Barry, and other recent shows that would lend themselves well to an animated format

TV Features crayola
Back to the drawing board: 14 TV shows that should do animated episodes
The Boys (Jasper Savage/Amazon Studios); Claws (TNT); Riverdale (Kailey Schwerman/The CW) Graphic: Jimmy Hasse

TV executives and creators alike are struggling to figure out how to make sure the show(s) goes on in the midst of a pandemic. For many, that’s meant putting a pin in things (for others, it’s meant just axing them despite existing renewal orders) and shifting season and midseason premieres to 2021. Network sitcoms like One Day At A Time and Black-ish have found another way to keep the conversation going—with animated specials. Kenya Barris’ family comedy first ventured into animation with “Please, Baby, Please,” its much-discussed anti-Trump episode from season four that was pulled by ABC in 2018, and then released on Hulu in August of this year.

ODAAT and Black-ish focused on timely matters for these stand-alone episodes—having “the talk” with your Trump-loving family and the importance of voting, respectively—to great success. And they got the A.V. Club staff thinking about what other shows, regardless of genre, would lend themselves well to an animated format. We then narrowed that list down to 14 ongoing series whose creativity, absurdity, and/or otherwordliness would run wild in animated episodes.

previous arrowBarry next arrow

Alec Berg and Bill Hader’s is one of the most nimble shows on TV, merging multiple genres in a season and deftly moving from dark humor to character study to action-thriller—. Such a bold, tonally rich show could certainly handle a departure from its live-action format for a stand-alone, episode that captures Barry’s (Hader) state of mind as he finds himself poised to be a lone wolf after Fuches’ (Stephen Root) betrayal. Equally ripe for the boundless adventure that animation would allow is NoHo Hank’s (Anthony Carrigan) backstory. Barry has hinted at a traumatic past for the most polite and genial gangster in pop culture, which may have prompted his move to California, but has done nothing to diminish his friendliness or made him any less of an “optometrist by nature.” An animated trip into Hank’s past would connect some dots, while allowing the show to reach new levels of absurdity. And just think of what it would be like to see Hank’s malapropisms come to life all around him. [Danette Chavez]

28 Comments

  • kpopwhat-av says:

    Fargo already did a largely animated episode, no?  Law of Non-Contradiction and Minsky?

  • evanwaters-av says:

    Shoulda done GLOW’s last season like this.

    • avcham-av says:

      Agreed. Farm it out to Japanese studios and do it up “Jem”- style.

      • lordtouchcloth-av says:

        Please tell me they’ll have two wrestlers in the ring just screaming “AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!” at each other for an entire episode without making a move.

    • bobfunch1-on-kinja-av says:

      Still could. Or the whole fourth season as a radio play/podcast/table read.

  • cariocalondoner-av says:

    Well, it’s over now, but I would have loved an animated episode of Crazy Ex-Girlfriend with more of Paula the Singing Raccoon:Also, we could have had:- Darryl as the Broomstick with a ‘tache- Josh as the Flip Flop – White Josh as the Buff Chipmunk- Heather as the Soaring Eagle (that would be, like, so on the nose …)

    • cariocalondoner-av says:

      Also, I kinda feel like I’ve already seen an episode of Happy Endings with the entire cast animated. Wait, no, not animated per se, but as puppets? All of them. We got SinBrad that one time, but I feel like I’ve already also seen Penny and Jane and all the others as puppets too. Anyway, I wouldn’t be mad if, especially with the current constraints on filming scenes together, they did a one-off 2020 episode solely with puppets.HAAAAAAAAAWWWWW SNAP!EDIT:While looking on YouTube for that SinBrad clip I came across this. Can’t believe I haven’t seen this already!

      • mattyoshea-av says:

        I forgot about this happening so thank you for sharing. Alex as a Trump supporter is the most perfect update to that character. 

  • dbzzang-av says:

    Vikas Khanna, the Indian Michelin-star chef feeding millions from New York
    Chef Vikas Khanna is up late most nights connecting with colleagues in India from his home on the east side of Manhattan, New York. The award-winning chef has been working across continents and time zones since April to organize what has become one of the world’s largest food drives. So far, his “Feed India” initiative has fed around 50 million Indians who have struggled to provide for their families during the coronavirus pandemic. India has the second-highest number of cases worldwide, behind the United States. As of October 12, more than seven million Indians had been 주식디비 with the virus and more than 108,000 had died. Khanna may have lived in the US for 20 years, but he still has strong ties to his homeland, where his beloved mother lives in Amritsar, in the northern state of Punjab. Khanna grew up in the same city and defied a difficult childhood to become one of the first Indian chefs to be awarded a Michelin star in America. He has written 35 books celebrating Indian food, directed a film, cooked for the Obamas, and hosted “MasterChef India.” But he says “Feed India” is his greatest achievement to date. “My brain said ‘don’t do it, you’ll get distracted’. But my heart said that ‘your mother didn’t raise you to be on Instagram and putting videos of your selfies,’” Khanna said. So, he set about creating a network of volunteers to deliver food to India’s most marginalized people — a near-impossible task during a nationwide lockdown that ordered public transport to stop and people to stay indoors. Answering the call Khanna didn’t plan to start an aid program — it almost happened by accident when an email encouraging non-resident Indians to donate to the country’s poor dropped into his inbox in late March. “In the email they had used a picture of elderly people holding empty food plates. A day after I donated to the cause, while speaking with my team in India, I encouraged them to contribute to the organization,” said Khanna. He soon realized it was a scam. “A team member who had seen the image earlier said the picture had been copied from a government website,” said Khanna. His money was gone, but the image of India’s destitute stayed with him. On April 1, Khanna tweeted a call-out for the names of aged care homes, orphanages or leprosy centers that needed help. More than 1,000 people replied. At the time, India was one week into a nationwide lockdown, more than 1,800 Indians had been infected with coronavirus and 41 had died, according to the country’s Health Ministry. More than 7,000 miles away, the situation was far worse in New York, where a sprawling field hospital had just opened in Central Park. From his apartment, Khanna could hear the near constant drone of ambulance sirens transporting people to hospital. At that stage, more than 45,000 people had been infected in the city and 1,374 had died, according to NYC Health. “Those were dark days,” said Khanna. “I lost relatives and friends to the pandemic. The prayer meetings through virtual calls were so painful,” he said. Khanna’s flourishing catering business was impacted. “Everything had to be canceled. We had to return advances. It was heartbreaking. I was signing a lease for a new restaurant in New York on March 31,” says Khanna. The restaurant deal fell through because of the pandemic. That’s when he decided to focus his attention on “Feed India.” His small team started shortlisting cities where food was needed. They reached out to dry food wholesalers within the city and found volunteers to pack food kits and deliver them to those in need. The first deliveries were made on April 3 in two cities at opposite ends of the country — Varanasi in Uttar Pradesh and Mangalore in Karnataka. “We were facing logistical issues every single day,” Khanna said. “On April 10, somebody siphoned off a truck full of food and amenities. The person I was dealing with knew I was running operations all the way from New York,” he said, by way of explanation. It was a huge setback. I called my mother and told her I can’t continue running the operation,” Khanna added. His elderly mother, Bindu Khanna, offered familiar words of encouragement. “I told Vikas not to lose heart. I told him it’s time to pay your country back by helping the poor and starving,” Bindu Khanna told CNN in a video call. Khanna realized he needed a trustworthy organization to help fillip his initiative in India. In mid-April, he sent a message to SN Pradhan, the Chief of India’s National Disaster Response Force (NDRF), who was already leading relief efforts during the pandemic. “Even though it was a one-man show from there, I told him we could be your hands, legs and ears in India. His endeavor has been a beautiful audacity. It has worked because it is deeply, deeply humanitarian,” says Pradhan. With the NDRF, Khanna has helped millions of migrant workers, transgender men and women, sex workers, HIV/AIDS patients, orphans, seniors and victims of the floods that swept through the eastern states of Bihar, West Bengal and Assam earlier this year. What started as a small initiative with his savings from the house and terrace of his Manhattan apartment now has the backing of several Indian corporate houses, including Pepsi, India Gate, Quaker Oats, Hyatt Regency and Global Funds for Widows. And it has extended beyond food to masks, sanitary pads and slippers. “People are actually forcing people to wear slippers,” he said. “They’re like, this guy in New York is upset that no one should walk barefoot and injure their feet.” A difficult start Born with club feet, Khanna initially wore leg braces and then wooden shoes. Doctors predicted he would never walk. He was 11 years old before he could run without support. “I do have memories of my walking, especially the sound of the shoes made… they were like thunderstorms. And, and you couldn’t help it because shoes are made out of wood,” he said. Khanna says he was bullied in school and that’s what drew him to the kitchen, where his doting grandmother taught him about the flavors of India. As a child, Khanna spent hours at the community kitchen at the Golden Temple in Amritsar, feeding hundreds of devotees. “I felt that at the Golden Temple, nobody judged me,” he said. When he finished school, he did a hotel management course, then worked in top hotels in India before moving to America in the year 2000. “After landing in New York, I decided to make it my home,” Khanna said. For about a year, Khanna sustained himself by working odd jobs, as a dog-walker, cat-sitter, delivery boy, dishwasher — anything to pay the bills. In 2001, Khanna started working for Sunil and Ramesh Shah at the couple’s Salaam Bombay restaurant. He was opening the restaurant on September 11 when planes hit the Twin Towers, just over a mile away. Khanna says restaurant’s business never really recovered after 9/11, and it closed down in June this year. It was in 2004 that Khanna got his big break. Impressed with his culinary skills, a restaurant client put him in touch with an employee at James Beard House, a non-profit organization that nurtures and honors chefs. Khanna says he received a standing ovation for his cooking: “For the first time I understood the potential of the Indian cuisine.” At the age of 34, he opened a cooking school in his New York apartment and took over a small kitchen for his catering business. But it was while running a “small hole in the wall” restaurant called Spice Route in 2006 that Khanna shot to fame. He was invited to make a guest appearance on “Kitchen Nightmares,” a reality show fronted by renowned Michelin-star chef Gordon Ramsay. Two years later, Khanna lost almost everything to the 2008 recession. “In Buddhism they say, you have to destroy the mandala to create a new one,” he said. After a bit of “soul searching and traveling,” Khanna decided to work under a famous chef at a Michelin-star restaurant in Paris. Khanna says he was made to wash utensils, clean and stock the cupboards. One day, Khanna decided to whip up a South Indian dish for the chef. The response floored him. “He told the sous chef, ‘tell this brown shit I’ll never eat from his hands,’” Khanna remembered. “That is when I think something triggered in my mind. I said, ‘I’m going back to New York. And I’m going to come back to France once I have a Michelin star.’” In December 2010, he opened Junoon, an Indian restaurant in New York, and earned a Michelin star just 10 months later. “It was such an emotional moment,” Khanna said. He remembers waiting to phone his then 93-year-old grandmother, to tell her firsthand that he’d finally achieved the ultimate honor in his field. She died soon after, just three weeks into his role on “MasterChef”. If feeding India during a pandemic wasn’t enough, the chef has just opened Ellora, a new restaurant in Dubai, and is working on his second movie project as well as writing a book about the “Feed India” initiative. Khanna can’t say when “Feed India” will end — so many people need help during a pandemic that shows few signs of easing — but he’s confident he’s on the right path. “If my grandmother was alive, she would say, ‘you weren’t born for the Michelin star, you were born to do this’,” he adds.

  • fcz2-av says:

    Superhero shows: The whole idea of having them is it was once novel to have a live action version of a traditionally animated story. There’s plenty of good DCAU shows and movies out there.See also: your suggestion for The Mandalorian. I get it you would like to see Mandalorian specific episodes, but we already have Rebels and The Clone Wars.

  • luasdublin-av says:

    The DC CW already had 2 animated tie in shows, one for Vixen and the other for The Ray .

  • laserface1242-av says:

    I watched the first two episodes of Atypical and gave up immediately when I saw some of the characters wearing Autism Speaks pendants. I’m not watching a show about people on the spectrum that supports those ableist assholes.

    • obtuseangle-av says:

      A couple years back, I was purchasing something at a store with my Dad next to me. When the cashier rung up my order, she asked if I wanted to donate towards Autism Speaks. My extremely quick and rather harsh refusal (I didn’t curse at her or anything, but my tone of voice wasn’t exactly pleasant) quickly prompted my Dad to clarify that I was on the spectrum myself, and that my response (which I don’t think he understood the why of yet) didn’t have anything to do with animosity towards Autistic people.After we left the store, my Dad asked me why I did what I did (not in judgement, as he assumed I had a reason, he just wanted to know what it was) and I explained about Autism Speaks’ awfulness.What makes them particularly insidious is that it’s basically a hate group masquerading as a charity to support the object of their hate, so you look like an asshole to people who don’t know better when you voice your opposition to their awful practices. There are so many decent Autistic support charities out there, the fact they continue to be the most prominent and successful (in terms of financial donations) one is incredibly aggravating to me.

  • marshalgrover-av says:

    Sure, it’s a fun deviation. But often these animated episodes look cheap and worse than a Homestar Runner short (not to dismiss the Brothers Chaps, but they know they’re making a webtoon not a TV show).

  • tobias-lehigh-nagy-av says:

    Niecy Nash keeps asking for an animated episode of Claws until she’s blue in the face!

  • lordtouchcloth-av says:

    Twin peaks. You know why.Or, rather, you don’t. Because no one can know why David Lynch does anything.

  • soylent-gr33n-av says:

    How about animated shows that need a live-action episode? Which I know would be hard as hell, esp. since a lot of animated shows have the same actor voicing multiple characters, but I’d love to see a live-action Venture Bros. or Archer.

  • thequakeroatsguy2-av says:

    Atlanta should do a rotoscoped episode. I don’t know why, but I feel like it would fit perfectly. 

  • pophead911-av says:

    I am going to respectfully disagree with you on Pose.  I think it would ruin the tone of the show.

  • bjackyll-av says:

    You picked the wrong Niecy Nash show, Reno 911 would have an AMAZING animated episode.

  • wangphat-av says:

    Star Trek The Animated series worked as basically a fourth season of the original series.I feel like It’s Always Sunny could do a great animated episode.

  • Fruitbat3-av says:

    Not every show is Community, dumbass.

  • bobfunch1-on-kinja-av says:

    I thought “yes” to almost all of these except Barry. And Evil … idk if I can see Evil going there.Euphoria is one show where I think they could lean into the social distancing. Mask up the actors and film half the show on Zoom, sez I.The Mandalorian, I suspect, is so CGI and graphically designed that they are practically animated to begin with.I could see something like Mindhunter – not animated – but done in a documentary style of narration and still crime-scene photography.

  • akinjaguy-av says:

    The Boys could probably benefit the most from something like this.  They could pack in massive effects and development into a 2 parter, that would allow them to push the story in new directions without going outside of the budget.

  • sheldoncooperjr-av says:

    Brooklyn Nine Nine

  • countdrunkula-av says:

    Some of these are no-brainers because, well, they HAVE been animated shows.I’d
    like to see live action versions of some animated shows. Family
    Guy/Simpsons are the most obvious. Anything from Adult Swim would be
    hilarious – real actors doing the Naruto ninja run, Venture Brothers
    (Patrick Warburton would barely need a costume, and Doctor Girlfriend
    would steal the show), and even our favorite Rick and Morty which was
    based on a live action movie trilogy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share Tweet Submit Pin