Mrs. America shifts the focus to Shirley Chisholm's historic run for president in stellar episode
TV Reviews Recap
“Legal discrimination between the sexes is, in almost every instance, founded on outmoded views of society and the pre-scientific beliefs about psychology and physiology. It is time to sweep away these relics of the past and set future generations free of them.”—Shirley Chisholm
One of the most impressive aspects of Mrs. America is how it brings so many stories of women who’ve been incredibly relevant and important throughout history to the forefront of our minds. I don’t know about your historical education, especially when it comes to American history, but I learned more about specific generals and battles from American wars than I did about women running for office. Again, this is based on my personal experience, and of course this was much before my time, but I’ve always been frustrated that I only learned about Congresswoman Shirley Chisholm as an adult. There was a documentary in 2005, Shirley Chisholm ’72: Unbought And Unbossed, but it must be said that narrativizing certain aspects of history help them stick in one’s memory.
It’s great to see Uzo Aduba in this dramatic role—it makes me wish we could get a series on just Shirley and her celebrated career, especially her win as the first Black woman elected to Congress. Instead, we focus on her run for president. We’re at the would-be end of Shirley’s campaign, though; she’s polling at 1% in the Democratic primary, with George McGovern a clear winner. Despite this, she decides to stay in the race until the Democratic National Convention. It’s 1972 and the ERA has been ratified by 18 states.
It’s a little painful watching this episode after our recent diverse Democratic primary that ended the way almost all of these primaries ended. The b-roll footage of interviews about having a female president is particularly painful considering how they seem to include a diversity of opinions that you don’t see often enough in media. Clearly, Shirley Chisholm’s run made history. But the glass ceiling didn’t seem as thick as concrete as it feels now.
An intriguing new detail about “Shirley” and the woman herself is how she’s being watched on a small scale as well. When Flo asks her about her Secret Service security, Shirley smirks and shrugs. “George Wallace got shot,” she says, referring to her rival’s near assassination. “They’re here to protect me.” “To protect? Or surveil?” says Flo, raising her eyebrows. “That man is always listening.” Reader, I laughed out loud. Shirley is constantly checking if her phone is tapped at her hotel room at the Democratic National Convention in Miami Beach, and even opens a vent and talks into it. It seems a little paranoid…except, of course, we know exactly why she’s right to do so.
What’s unfortunate is how Shirley’s other concerns are dismissed by the people around her. We know history—we know that McGovern barely shows up in the history books. But she’s told over and over again it’s time for her to drop out. Rep. Ron Dellums (Norm Lewis) of the National Black Caucus tells her that she seems to represent women more than Black people. Most egregious is how the National Women’s Political Caucus decides to endorse McGovern. While Betty Friedan is all in for Shirley, Bella outright calls Shirley’s campaign a joke. Shirley realizes they’re treating her as symbolic of what could be instead of taking her for what she is: an actual candidate. Bella attempts to take her comments back, but Shirley is stunned and frustrated that it’s not the NWPC’s immediate imperative to back her, but instead compromise and back McGovern.
And as the NWPC, especially Gloria, finds out, such compromises require such constant concessions as to not be worth it. They learn this first hand when they force a vote on abortion on the floor of the convention, as Gloria was adamant to do in the last episode. Despite the fact that Gloria got McGovern staffer Gary Hart’s (John Palladino) word, a McGovern staffer looking above the convention center says to turn face because “They might actually get the votes.” Dozens of men, who had very happily given women their seats so they could vote, start running back, eager to toe the party line. Gary Hart dismiss Gloria’s protests as she points out that they avoided talking too honestly about the brutality of illegal abortions specifically for this vote to go through. He tells her, “I’m sick of you women!” Gloria leaves the floor in tears, saying, “We’re just wombs to them.”
By contrast, before McGovern takes the floor, Shirley gives a rousing speech about her candidacy. Unfortunately, she still has to concede later. Even her husband Conrad (Brandon J. Dirden) says so. Let’s take a moment here to talk about the Chisholms’ marriage. Unlike Fred and Phyllis’ relationship, where there’s a fair bit of politics and compromise within the relationship, or Gloria and Frank’s relationship, where there’s a sense of abstaining and avoiding a settled relationship, the Chisholms have no such qualms or compromises. Conrad’s support does not come with strings, concessions, or a fight for power. Shirley is emotionally beside herself, breaking down in front of him after checking the phones again, and he’s there to calm her. Conrad is the antithesis of Fred—he’s with Shirley all the way.
Speaking of the Schlaflys, Phyllis is finding that compromise is the way to go for her and the STOP ERA group—that is, other women compromising for her. When various women from various chapters make speeches at a STOP ERA event, Mary Frances (Melinda Page Hamilton) of the Louisiana chapter of STOP ERA takes it to a racist place, talking about how terrible it would be for the genders to be integrated the way the races have. People clap uncomfortably, and later Alice tells Phyllis she should call out Mary.
Instead, Phyllis encourages Alice to call out Mary in front of everyone, which seems incredibly naïve of Alice. Mary Frances and several other women of the coalition start walking out, but Phyllis holds an “election” for Mary and convinces her to stay. She actually appoints several state leaders of STOP ERA, including her friend and neighbor Rosemary Thomson (Melanie Lynskey). Then Phyllis says they’ll have to use identical language in speeches and phone calls—for unity, of course.
In the end, Gloria, Bella, and Betty find McGovern’s candidacy too hard of a pill to swallow, their clapping desultory when he officially wins the primary. They liven up when Shirley appears on stage, their tears and love for her apparent. Too bad their compromise in a candidate isn’t going to make a difference in the long run. At least Shirley’s run will.
Stray observations
- Amma Asante, the director of Belle and A United Kingdom, directs this episode, which is how we get moments like Phyllis’ maid’s expression of disbelief when Phyllis tells her to take the Schlaflys’ cans of expired food.
- Speaking of canned food, Phyllis’s nuclear bunker is a reminder of where her passions (and fears) really lie.
- I’m going to be thinking of Alice’s line, “I’ve spoken with exactly four men,” for a while.
- If you wondered why you were thinking of Beyoncé throughout the episode, it’s because of the song “Are You My Woman (Tell Me So)” by the Chi-lites, which plays over b-roll of the DNC. Beyoncé sampled it for “Crazy in Love”; the use here is a clever way to parallel strong Black women in this episode without compromising historical accuracy.
- Fun fact: Before her Secret Service detail, Chisholm’s husband Conrad was her bodyguard.
- At one point, Aduba wears the exact outfit Chisholm wears in the main image of her Wikipedia entry.
- Martin Luther King, Jr. once called George Wallace “the most dangerous racist in America today” in 1968. Shirley still visited Wallace after the attempt on his life. A class act.
- I’ve probably lived in the Bay Area too long, but my first reaction to Shirley’s endorsement from the Black Panthers was, “Lucky!” Rep. Dellums was actually from the East Bay, and was Mayor of Oakland in 2007. It makes his thinking that Shirley doesn’t represent Black interests even more egregious! And it makes me think of this clip from the Golden Globes a few years ago.
19 Comments
I keep looking at that photo and wondering what Columbo has to do with all of this.
Being holed up, like everyone, I’ve been binging OITNB and it has made me even more amazed with the life and love Uzo brought to Suzanne – the performance became so much more excellent to me seeing the character’s growth in rapid succession and I’m glad it brought Uzo Aduba firmly into the spotlight.Here, again, she shines and did so already in the earlier episodes in brief show-stealing moments but this episode is a highlight for me.Give her all the awards. All of them.So far absolutely loving this series and, indeed, would love to see a series based solely on Chisholm (played by Aduba).
We know history—we know that McGovern barely shows up in the history books.This is not an accurate appraisal.
He’s a footnote. He did nothing.
He may have “done nothing,” but he’s still more commonly known than the arguably more significant Chisholm…thanks to (wait for it) history books.
Nonsence. he did plenty. For one thing, he was a war hero.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_McGovern
Some punk sitting home in his underwear denigrating a guy who flew 35 missions over Germany, was a leader of the opposition to the Viet Nam War, and was instrumental in the creation of the World Food Programme.
This is a completely incorrect statement. Please see my comments on the “Jill”episode. I’m on my phone so copying and pasting is a nightmare. Briefly here, and you really should go read my comments because I was there, lived through this time, and was actively involved in it, McGovern was one of the last great liberals we had. Had he been elected, the last 50 years would have been completely different. He did a lot and is not a “footnote.” I’ll also discuss some of the other issues raised by a commenters here, about Betty Friedan in particular.
Pretty accurate, actually.
McGovern was a hero in WWII (flew 35 missions over Germany) a very effective senator, a major force in the opposition to Viet Nam, the Democratic nominee for president, and was an instrumental force in fighting world hunger. i suspect he’s in decent history books.
The show’s take on Chisholm was fantastic and everyone deserves a lot of credit. I think I disagree with the review a bit, but actually towards the positive, as I felt Aduba’s Chisholm was shown as an intentionally flawed individual. There was a lot to admire in her, but she was as deluded as the others, just in a different way. Again, not a negative in anyway as it added a layer to the character and her actions which made her much more admirable than having a perfect saint would have been.
As a sidenote, as much as I loved the episode, there was a narrative decision that bothered me during it and really stuck out to me while reading the recap here. The 1972 Democratic Primary was extremely contentious and there was a really strong ‘Anyone but McGowern’ southern Democrat movement that actively that tried to stop the nomination. The core attempt at it was trying to change the delegate distribution for California, who had a winner-take-all approach to allocating the delegates. Now, and at this point I hope I’m corrected if I get things wrong, the thing was that if the candidate vote had gone to the second round, that would have freed up the delegates, at which point McGovern’s position would have become a lot more fragile.Now I don’t expect the show to tell you that because it wasn’t the perspective of any of the narrative characters here. But having read on it recently, it did provide a lot of context to those people who turned against Chisholm. It wasn’t a betrayal just because they were dismissive of her, but because they saw that McGovern’s candidacy was still at risk at that point and Chisholm’s actions were endangering it. I hope I get corrected if I got something wrong here.
Agreed, this episode did a fantastic job staging the conflict between ideals and politics, a conflict that progressives have never really handled well. The arguments between Chisholm and Bella Abzug can easily map onto Sanders vs Biden right now. At the same time the show demonstrates how conservatives have been more successful at addressing this conflict by goading their followers into line.
I’d add that the episode also highlights of both. The McGovern campaign reneging on the abortion promise was a blatant example of the political calculation being taken too far, but I also loved the women’s delegate address. They got so swept up by the idealism of Chisholm that they weren’t just neutral on McGovern, but hostile towards him and Gloria refuses to stay on the stage for him despite her stated importance to him. No matter what, they still needed his support, but at that moment it came across as they thought that they really didn’t.
^This.Mrs. America is doing such a great job of dramatising the ideals v politics thing so well.
I’m a Brit so don’t know any of these people (except for Gloria Steinem). Cate Blanchett is like the Dolores Umbridge of the story. So charming and nice and pretty much the devil! She manipulated Sarah Paulson’s character into being the one to call out the racists Southern women so she could save the day and I disagree with pretty mu b every word out of her mouth..but…it’s Cate Blanchett! And I love her!I’m a bit OITNB fan so it was great to se Uzo Aduba show her talent outside of the role of Suzanne. She has real presence and charisma however I find this whole series tough to watch as you just have so many awful attitudes and terrible people! Has John Slattery ever NOT played a sexist privileged asshole from earlier days??Fantastic cast, classy production but hard to enjoy
Yeah, the scenes between Schlafly and her crew are so good that it makes my skin crawl because of what they did, so it makes it hard as hell to watch.
I’m British and my wife’s Colombian, so we’re not very familiar with many of the people featured so far in this series, so it’s great to read these reviews and get a little more context.Cate Blanchett is great at showing Phyliss as someone who does not like it when she’s not in control and isn’t above insidious manipulation. Her grin always looks both uneasy and too wide, like she’s about to eat someone but will pretend to enjoy it. One thing my missus and I didn’t really get was when Shirley appeared onstage at the end – was that just her being classy and graciously accepting defeat whilst showing ‘no hard feelings’ towards McGovern, or did she temporarily join forces with him or something?
It was classy, because that was the kind of lady she was, but it was also expected of her. The other candidates that had run for the nomination like Muskie and Humphrey were also up there. Once the intra-party fight of the primary is done, people really do need to unite behind a candidate if they want to have any chance of winning the presidency.