Saturday Night Live’s 15 best double-duty hosts

Serving as host and musical guest in the same SNL episode is hard, but stars like Paul Simon, Stevie Wonder, Britney Spears and Bruno Mars made it look easy

TV Lists Saturday Night Live
Saturday Night Live’s 15 best double-duty hosts
Clockwise from bottom left: Paul Simon (NBCU Photo Bank/NBCUniversal via Getty Images), Dolly Parton (NBCU Photo Bank/NBCUniversal via Getty Images), Stevie Wonder and Eddie Murphy (Anthony Barboza/Getty Images), and Lady Gaga (Dana Edelson/NBCU Photo Bank/NBCUniversal via Getty Images) Graphic: The A.V. Club

As Bad Bunny makes his Saturday Night Live debut on October 21, he’ll be joining a relatively small group of performers who pulled double duty as both the host and the musical guest on the same show. Make no mistake: that shit is hard. You’ve got to be funny, you’ve got to be creative, you’ve got to switch modes from acting to singing at the drop of a hat. And let’s be honest: some musicians just aren’t all that charismatic when it comes to delivering the opening monologue and performing in sketches. That’s not in any way a dig; being funny on the fly and having musical talent are two entirely different things, both of which are very difficult. But that just makes the rare few who actually pull it off even more special.

Sometimes a performer surprises with their versatility, like Paul Simon and his disarming humor and charm. Sometimes it’s not much of a surprise when a musician crushes it as a host—with all that charisma, it would’ve been more shocking if Bruno Mars had bombed. And sometimes there’s an artist with a truly uncanny talent who can bridge the gap between music and sketch, like Ariana Grande and her vocal impressions. Each of the musicians on this list brought something special to the table when they hosted and performed on SNL, and we think that’s worth celebrating. Fingers crossed Bad Bunny pulls it off, too.

previous arrowPaul Simon next arrow
Paul Simon’s Monologue Worries - SNL

Show dates: October 18, 1975; November 20, 1976; May 10, 1986; December 19, 1987) There have been several musicians who also hosted SNL multiple times, but Paul Simon holds the record for most times pulling double-duty with four appearances. (Technically, it’s five if you count the show’s 100th episode in 1980, but many SNL enthusiasts discount that one because of its non-traditional structure.) His first time hosting, on October 18, 1975, was only the second episode of the show. Simon came in and established himself as an early favorite with creator Lorne Michaels, and his willingness to laugh at himself made him an easy scene partner for the cast. The next year, he came back for a Thanksgiving-themed episode in a turkey costume, which has become one of SNL’s most famous moments. Simon performed a whopping six songs in his first double-duty episode (the format was a lot looser back then), five in his second episode, three in his third (he opened the show with an exceptional “You Can Call Me Al”), and just one in his fourth (The Mariachi Vargas did the other performance). [Jen Lennon]

25 Comments

  • panthercougar-av says:

    I don’t believe Mick Jagger hosted this episode, but the time he appeared as Keith Richards alongside Mike Myers playing Mick was hilarious. I can’t seem to find a good unedited video of it.

    • misstwosense-av says:

      I absolutely can picture the exact sketch you’re talking about.

    • starvenger88-av says:

      I think they did a Point/Counterpoint bit?

    • osbl-av says:

      Luke Perry hosted. Mick was the musical guest promoting his solo album, “Wandering Spirit” (Early ‘93). He also did a deep cut appearance on Wayne’s World from that week’s dress (it ended up on some random one-off WW special, and not SNL proper) where he did the WW token “rock star is unexpectedly smart about something” bit based on his legit background in economics education. He did double-duty in 2012, IIRC.

      • panthercougar-av says:

        Mick did do double duty in 2012, I remember that episode. Interest that he popped up in two sketches this past weekend after we were talking about him. 

  • akanefive-av says:

    The only bad thing about Donald Glover’s appearance is that his song “Saturday” has never been officially released, which is insane because it’s incredible. 

  • SpaceyKacie-av says:

    Justice for Chance the Rapper, whose hockey sketch is an all time great. I think they’ve really missed an opportunity with Lil Nas X after Montero came out – his album announcement sketches and music videos prove he has acting skills and comedic timing and I think he’d be awesome with double duty.

  • terrifiedvictim-av says:

    Ah, yes. The digital short in 1983.

  • carrercrytharis-av says:

    Were they calling them ‘digital shorts’ in 1983?

  • memo2self-av says:

    Hello? Ray Charles? “The Young Caucasians”? “Please don’t tell him”?

  • atomicwalrusx-av says:

    Garth Brooks: also pretty good from what I remember.

  • hoodedcrow-av says:

    The biggest missing star I see is Garth Brooks.  I wasn’t a fan of his music and wasn’t expecting all that much, but that dude was ridiculously funny.  Especially in the two sketches with Mango.

  • drblank76-av says:

    What about Garth Brooks? He was hilarious and hosted twice iirc. I think the musical guest on one of them was Chris Gaines though. Old French Whore, the best Mango sketch, full Smurf body paint, The Devil Can’t Write No Love Song, Cowboy Campfire… he was great!

    • edkedfromavc-av says:

      I can still sing some of the song snippets from “Devil Can’t Write No Love Song.” Can’t recall a single line from either of the Chris Gaines songs.

  • southpawcraig-av says:

    Sting back in 1991 played Billy Idol in the famous Sinatra Group sketch. 

  • fuckfuck666-av says:

    I feel that there should have been a nod to the WORST double duty performance on SNL, which in my opinion was Frank Zappa on Oct. 21, 1978.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share Tweet Submit Pin