The Pope’s Exorcist review: Not even the power of Russell Crowe should compel you to see this
The Oscar winner brings an Italian accent that's even more implausible than Chris Pratt's Super Mario voice to this campy, overlong mess
Film Reviews Pope
While the entire film Internet obsessed over Chris Pratt’s Mario accent, Russell Crowe has quietly slipped in with The Pope’s Exorcist, speaking in an Italian-a accent-a that’s every bit as insane as the Greek one he brought to Thor: Love And Thunder. He also delivers dialogue in actual Italian as well, as in this film’s opening sequence where he cuts to the chase in a small-town exorcism, immediately challenging the demon to jump into a pig, where its brains are promptly blown out. But this is a feature for audiences who may not want to read subtitles for the duration, so he switches up to accented English the rest of the time.
That can be amazing to watch, when he’s dramatically intoning, “My diocese is Rome! My bishop is the Pope!” to a committee which is determined to find him out as a fraud, and when he’s trying to be sensitive with platitudes like, “A mother’s love is the closest thing we know to God’s love.” The Crow said it better, but the Crowe says it funnier.
He’s equaled in the accent department by a possessed boy (Peter DeSouza-Feighoney) speaking with a Cockney-accented demonic voice (Ralph Ineson) that sounds almost exactly like Andy Serkis. Not the vocal chameleon Serkis who played Gollum and Caesar, though; more the un-mo-capped version if he were five beers in at the local pub. The child grabs his mother’s breasts and yells, “Baby’s hungry, you fat cow!” Then he threatens to have sex with Crowe’s Father Gabriele Amorth and bring him to climax. It’s impossible to take any of this remotely seriously, or find it particularly frightening. But it is its own sort of fun, at least for a while.
Ostensibly based on true events, with the real Amorth claiming to have performed over 50,000 exorcisms, this ’80s-set movie replaces the actual pontiff of the time, Poland’s John Paul II, with an unnamed Italian Pope played by Franco Nero, the original Django. If that doesn’t appropriately set the tone, nothing will, unless it’s Crowe riding around the Spanish countryside (the movie was actually shot in Ireland) on a Ferrari motor scooter half his width.
The young boy, Henry, is living in a run-down Spanish abbey when he gets possessed. He’s staying in the abbey with his mother and sister because his father recently got impaled through the head in a car accident (though the real reason seems to be so that there can be Americans in the story without fake accents, so just go with it.) Deducing rather quickly that Henry’s not faking it—because he knows things he shouldn’t—Amorth can’t skip to the ending as easily as in the first exorcism. Worse, the demon proclaims it will reveal hidden secrets to bring down the entire Vatican.
Is that really a bad thing, though? How many abuses and cover-ups in the ’90s and beyond might have been prevented if this demon merely got its way in 1987? So the creature picked a good moment in time, but for the fact that Italian Russell Crowe was around.
There’s an undeniable camp appeal to all this, as Henry’s eyes keep changing colors and developing extra irises, as Amorth talks to statues and has visions of World War II, and as his sidekick, Father Esquibel (Daniel Zovatto), keeps stupidly engaging the demon after being repeatedly instructed not to. About an hour in, though, things start to drag. Director Julius Avery made an impressive original superhero story with Samaritan, but feels more constrained by formula this time around. Hang in there and be rewarded with naked apparitions, CG fire and, I kid you not, a set-up for a whopping number of sequels.
Frankly, an hour and 43 minutes is just too long for this sort of thing. Aside from the family’s traumatic loss, we’re not given much reason to care about them, and too much time gets wasted on the priests’ backstories, which most will catch on to pretty quickly. A tighter edit focused purely on the crazy bits could be a big cult hit; as is, it might be timed just right for a 4/20 viewing with plenty of smoke breaks.
The Pope’s Exorcist opens in theaters on April 14.
23 Comments
Place your bets on:Crowe needed the moneyCrowe thought it sounded like a fun shoot in a nice place (Ireland)Someone blackmailed Crowe into doing it (or he did it as a favor)Crowe has lost his mind
All 4 options could be used to describe almost every Russell Crowe career choice in the past decade.
Hmm:
5. He’s got a bad reputation as an employee so a lot of major directors (especially younger ones) don’t want to work with him
5. Chasin’ demons, makin’ songs and foightin’ ‘round the world!
Are you not underwhelmed?
This deserves a lot more likes than it got.
A version of option 3: He agreed to make this film as part of a deal where he gets to make the film he wants, possibly as director.
I’m sold.
Not even the power of Russell Crowe should compel you to see thisWith a clickbait headline like this, you wouldn’t expect a “C” rating….
YES! I came here expecting D or lower.
“Don’t watch this movie, because it’s terrible. Except also watch this movie, because it’s only mostly terrible.”
Director Julius Avery made an impressive original superhero story with Samaritan, but feels more constrained by formula this time around.
The AVC Review of Samaritan gave it a C, the same letter grade as this.
Wait. This is not a comedy? How is that possible when Russel Crowe is clearly doing H. Jon Benjamin’s accent as the Special Father in Lucy the Daughter of the Devil (a grossly underrated series)?
I can’t remember the last time anyone threatened to bring me to climax.
He also delivers dialogue in actual Italian as well, as in this film’s opening sequence where he cuts to the chase in a small-town exorcism, immediately challenging the demon to jump into a pig, where its brains are promptly blown out. But this is a feature for audiences who may not want to read subtitles for the duration, so he switches up to accented English the rest of the time.Shouldn’t that be Latin?
If you go back far enough, isn’t Latin just very old Italian?
I believe what we call Italian was just one of the numerous dialects of the languages spoken prior to the unification of the country (maybe the one from around Florence?) but it was the one selected to be the national language, originally it might have been as little as 2-3% of the people who spoke it. So, it could be one of the numerous languages and dialects that splintered off Latin.
Interesting! (user name checks out)
I did a couple of years of Italian at university and the history of the language was one of the things we covered. It was about 17 years ago, though so my memory of the details may be a little sketchy.
and very old French and very old Spanish.
Started watching what was presented as a documentary on the priest this is based on and got about five minutes in before I had to stop as it was clearly taking him at his word. (He genuinely believed this shit).
“Ostensibly based on true events, with the real Amorth claiming to have performed over 50,000 exorcisms….”By the end of his life Amorth claimed to have performed 150,000 exorcisms, which sounds amazing unless you consider the possibility that he was full of shit.Turns out that he used to perform “silent” exorcisms on people making confession. Dude would literally decide you were possessed by a demon, have an imaginary conversation in his head while you thought he was listening to you, and bam, that’s an exorcism, if not a very cinematic one.
He’s looking a bit like Guillermo del Toro playing Pappy McPoyle.